Cross FIRE: I have my opinion, but I like to see what other people think as well. I take two players or teams and put them against each other one on one and see who comes out on top.
There was a time when I think the answer to this question was obvious. But now with Peyton coming back from an injury and Eli coming off of his second superbowl victory, I don’t think the answer is quite as clear. I know what I think, but what do you think?
Eli Manning - 2011: QB Rating: 92.9, Comp. %: 61, Yards: 4,933, TD: 29, INT: 16′
Peyton Manning - 2010: QB Rating: 91.9, Comp. %: 66.3, Yards: 4,700, TD: 33, INT : 17
- Eli vs. Peyton Manning: Who Has Better Tools at the Quarterback Position? (bleacherreport.com)
- Manning Role Reversal: As Questions Dog Peyton, Eli Has All The Answers (denver.cbslocal.com)